Are we back?
Ehh, sort of. I just want to talk about this treasure trove of Phil Lynott tracks that I recently spent the best part of £90 on. The good and the bad, though there’s not much bad — it’s me being incredibly anal. I figure it’ll be easiest to go through the set disc-by-disc (excluding already-released albums), since each one is either an album or a theme. But first…
The sleeve notes — in reality a booklet — are written by Mark Blake, a man I have never heard of, but I will bet everything I own that he is bald. You're practically gagging to be bald with a name like that. Anyway, a cursory search tells me his work is often published in right-leaning newspapers. Oh dear. It’s on brand, really; the booklet is riddled with obvious misinformation and inaccuracies. Perhaps he’d just done a piece for the Telegraph and muscle memory kicked in. The most egregious examples are as follows:
He claims a recording titled “Wanted Alive” by short-lived trio Baby Face — a group consisting of Lynott plus Deep Purple heavyweights Ritchie Blackmore and Ian Paice — is “finally released here”. That song is not included in this box set.
He claims “Ode to Liberty” was performed on The Old Grey Whistle Test in 1981. This is not true; it was “Ode to a Black Man”.
Perhaps the worst of them all: “Philip Lynott died on January 4, 1986, shortly before his 36th birthday”. Eh… Lynott turned 36 on August 20, 1985. January is not shortly before (or after) August, so even if he got the age wrong, or mixed up “before” and “after”, his claim still makes no sense.
There’s plenty of information and stories to feast on in the booklet — some I knew already — but the fact he was unable to get some basic facts right shrouds them all with doubt.
Fatalistic Attitude was recorded in 1981 as the follow-up to his debut solo album Solo in Soho, but the record company was uncomfortable with the downbeat title (and I assume lyrics, too) and never released it in its original form. A few songs were replaced, a few other changes were made, and it was finally released as The Philip Lynott Album in September 1982. It’s not different enough to be interesting to fair-weather fans, but it’s really interesting to me. Differences I’ve noticed between Fatalistic Attitude and The Philip Lynott Album include:
The order of several tracks has been shuffled around.
“Somebody Else’s Dream” and “Hate” are replaced by the more accessible “Yellow Pearl” and “Together”. In fact, “Somebody Else’s Dream” ended up being the B-side of the “Together” single. “Hate” was discarded entirely, making it the only previously unreleased song on the album.
“Ode to Liberty (The Protest Song)” features Scott Gorham on guitar, rather than Mark Knopfler. I love Scott, but Knopfler elevates the song to a whole new level.
“Little Bit of Water” and “Old Town” are in their original pitch (they were tuned up on The Philip Lynott Album), making them a little more bittersweet, which I really like.
“Little Bit of Water” has an extra verse.
“The Man’s a Fool” has an intro with a cockney man talking about “an urgent consignment of cauliflowers”.
There are a few minor changes in the mixes too (I actually lean towards preferring the Fatalistic Attitude versions), but that’s basically it. It’s nice to see how each song evolved, but there’s little more than that to get excited about.
This is where it starts to get more interesting for me. Despite the majority of this disc being songs and mixes I’d already heard, B-sides, different mixes and so on, there is a serious treat included. “The Lady Loves to Dance” is a song performed by Lynott and Junior Giscombe (who has a hit in 1981 with “Mama Used to Say”), produced by Tony Visconti, and all ready to be released in the mid-80s before being pulled by the record company at the last minute. The final mix had never been released before, and it is one of my all-time favourite songs. Before last Friday, I had been listening to a poor-quality demo for the past ten years. This song was my holy grail; every couple of months I’d scour the net to see if anyone has uploaded the fabled master mix. You can therefore imagine hearing the final version was like letting out a sneeze ten years in the making. It is so good — an absolute masterclass of 80s dance rock. Plus, we get the 7” mix and the 12” mix! So why wasn’t the song released back then? The answer is, of course, racism. They recorded several other demos together, none of which have seen the light of day.
Another disc consisting of songs I’d already heard — they’re all either from albums already released or searchable online. Still warrants a mention, though. Most of these are duets with Gary Moore; tracks 1-3 and 7-9 are taken from his Back on the Streets (1978) and Run for Cover (1985) albums respectively, including the hits “Parisienne Walkways” and “Out in the Fields”, plus a few live versions of these songs. I already own both these albums (my 2002 copy of Run for Cover includes the aforementioned live versions, too), so what interests me more are the songs which make up the filling of the sandwich (Gary Moore is the bread, so to speak).
“Tennessee Stud” is a cover of the Jimmy Driftwood song, performed here by Terry Woods (The Pogues, Steeleye Span, etc.) as a duet with Lynott. I had only discovered this version a few months ago, and it’s already one of my most played tracks of 2026. It’s the perfect intersection between country, rock ‘n’ roll, and new wave.
“Please Don’t Leave Me” is a duet between Lynott and John Sykes, who was a Thin Lizzy guitarist for their final album, before going on to join Whitesnake. It’s a nice little soft rock ballad that suffers from typical 80s production — I feel like it would’ve sounded much nicer had it been recorded five years earlier.
“A Tribute to Sandy Denny” is a song I’ve actually already written about, so you might as well just go here.
Two whole discs of demos! Now, most of these I’d already heard in terrible quality on YouTube, but here they all are, fully restored. Again, it feels so good to listen to these without tape hiss drowning most of them out for the first time. “Reggae 2” seems to be an early version of “Talk in ‘79”, which featured on Lynott’s Solo in Soho. “The Story of My Life”, “Can’t Get Away”, and “Catholic Charm” are three which I’m very pleased have been restored. In another, better universe, “Can’t Get Away” was a hit single in the mid-80s. There are quite a few interesting inclusions here, too. A version of “Together” with Paul Brady on backing vocals is a winner for me, even if it is incredibly weird to hear his voice alongside electronic drums and synths. “Blue Parris” is a song I’d heard people mention in certain corners of the internet previously, but no version of it (to my knowledge) had ever surfaced. It borrows some lyrics (or vice versa) from “Don’t Let Him Slip Away”, a Thin Lizzy demo, but is somehow even darker. The song title also makes it obvious those lyrics are about Lynott’s father, Cecil Parris, whom he never really knew. It’s fascinating to listen to a subject Lynott never publicly spoke about.
These discs also include several Grand Slam demos — a band Lynott formed after Thin Lizzy’s demise — which are quite strong. “Crazy” and “Harlem” have been favourites of mine for a while… again, only in poor quality. Once again, I must stress just how good it feels to hear them properly. Consider the scraps we had available to us beforehand. You’d think some of the magic of the mystery would be lost now we have proper versions, but no.
Finally, I’d like to mention “I’m Still Alive”, recorded with Huey Lewis and the News. This could have easily been a hit had it made it to release, perhaps as a “comeback” single for Lynott once he’d managed to overcome his drug addictions in an alternate universe. It is pure, distilled mid-80s pop rock; all I could see for the first 15 seconds of the song was Phil Collins.
The last disc, for me, is not much to shout about. It’s just a collection of rehearsals for a tour featuring Lynott, Mark Nauseef, Gus Isidore, Jerome Rimson, and Darren Wharton. A couple of the songs (“Girls”, “Fatalistic Attitude”) are perhaps better than the studio recordings, but others (“King’s Call”, “Solo in Soho”) just don’t have the energy required to be good live songs (at least not here — Grand Slam played versions of these which are levels above these recordings).
Is this box set good? Yes, for me. Is it worth £86.99? Maybe, for me. For anyone who only has a passing interest, you’re probably better off just listening to them on streaming services. Really, I just wanted to write all this to justify complaining about the errors in the sleeve notes.